What Is Old Guard in BDSM? The Leather Tradition and the New Guard

Also called: New Guard, Leather, Old Guard leather, Leather tradition

Old Guard is the name for the early gay men's leather scene that formed in the United States after World War II, and for the formal style it's remembered for: protocol, hierarchy, mentorship, and leathers earned rather than bought. New Guard is the broader, looser community that came after it. How strict and unified the Old Guard really was is disputed, including by people who were there.

This page covers what "Old Guard" means today, where the leather tradition came from, and the rules it's known for. Then it compares Old Guard with New Guard, sorts the history from the legend, and shows where the tradition still lives in D/s.

What "Old Guard" Means

"Old Guard" gets used in three different ways, and it helps to know which one someone means.

All three sit inside "leather," the wider culture of leather clubs, bars, families, contests and gear that grew from the same roots and now includes people of every gender and orientation.

Where the Leather Tradition Came From

The leather tradition grew out of World War II. Many gay men had their first experience of an all-male world in the military, with its discipline, ranks and loyalty, and when they came home they looked for something like it in civilian life.

Gay motorcycle clubs gave them that. The Satyrs Motorcycle Club, founded in Los Angeles in 1954, is still running and calls itself the oldest gay men's motorcycle club in the world. Clubs like it borrowed military-style rules, ranks and insignia, and wore leather because riders did. Marlon Brando's look in The Wild One (1953) spread the biker image across the country, and leather bars became the places where the scene met.

Guy Baldwin, a therapist and leatherman, wrote in 1991 that this style had settled by the mid-to-late 1950s. The anthropologist Gayle Rubin describes two pulls in it from the start: military formality on one side, and the rebellious, disorderly biker world on the other.

The Old Guard Rules

The Old Guard rules were never written down. As Baldwin described them, they were passed on by example rather than taught, they varied from city to city, and few men followed all of them. His own list covers:

Other writers add customs that have become part of the legend: full leathers earned through the community's recognition rather than bought, learning from a mentor, and the often-repeated rule that you had to bottom before you could top. Some circles held to these. Many didn't.

Old Guard vs New Guard

New Guard isn't a group anyone joined. It's the name for the community that came after, as leather and kink grew, opened up and changed. The differences usually drawn between the two look like this:

Old Guard (as remembered) New Guard What historians add
Who's in Gay men Every gender and orientation Women's leather has its own history, now collected by the Leather Archives & Museum
How you learn From a mentor, by example Classes, books, munches, online Both ways existed from the start, and both exist now
Roles Fixed: you're a top or a bottom Switching accepted Practice varied from circle to circle
Rules Unwritten protocol Negotiation and consent frameworks The protocol varied by city and circle
Style Formal Casual A difference of degree, not a clean break

The New Guard's acceptance of switching is one of the clearest changes. So is the move to spoken negotiation and named consent frameworks in place of rules everyone was supposed to absorb.

Was the Old Guard Real? History vs Myth

The people, clubs, bars and customs were real. What's disputed is the idea of a single, strict rulebook that everyone shared.

The doubts come from inside leather. Baldwin called "Old Guard" a misnomer for the early scene and suggested "Early Guard" or "First Guard" instead. Rubin argued in 1998 that the Old and New Guard shorthand exaggerates and oversimplifies both the past and the present: formal and casual styles, and strict and relaxed manners, were all there from the late 1940s. She also pointed out that AIDS killed many of the people who built the scene's institutions and passed on its culture in the 1980s, which made the change afterwards look like a sharper break than it was.

Race Bannon, active in the leather scene since 1972, wrote in 2023 that many of the men later named as Old Guard elders described nothing like the strict system to him, and that anything resembling it was rare. The fair reading is to respect the history and not treat the legend as law.

Old Guard in D/s Today

The tradition still shapes D/s, mostly through practices that outlived the label:

Respecting the tradition doesn't mean anyone can use it against you. Nobody owes a leather pedigree to join the community, and nobody earns your obedience by calling themselves Old Guard. If someone uses the label to demand a newcomer's submission, treat it as a red flag. Real submission is chosen, negotiated and can be withdrawn, in any tradition.

Old Guard FAQ

What is New Guard? The name for the broader, looser leather and kink community that followed the early scene. It's a label for a style, not a group you join.

What does "earning your leathers" mean? The custom of wearing full leather only once the community recognised you, rather than because you bought it. Some circles still keep it.

Is Old Guard only for gay men? It began in gay men's clubs and bars. Leather culture today includes people of every gender and orientation.

Do you have to bottom before you top? Some Old Guard circles said so, and some people still believe it. It isn't a rule, and starting as a Dominant is fine.

What is a leather family? A chosen household in the leather community, usually with a head of household and its own customs.

Is "Old Guard" an insult? Sometimes. It's used for rigid or gatekeeping elders, and it's also a label some people wear with pride.

Read next

RACK vs SSC vs PRICK Explained

All D/s terms